A man is looking at a photo of a man on the wall and states, “Brothers and sisters I have actually none, yet this man’s dad is my father’s son.”
Who is the guy in the picture in relation to the guy looking at the picture?
The man in the photo is his son. Due to the fact that he doesn’t have any brothers or sisters, the statement mine father’s kid is himself. A shortened variation would be this man’s dad is myself, for this reason he is the father of the male in the picture.
You are watching: Brothers and sisters have i none riddle
The man in the snapshot is his son. Since he doesn’t have any kind of brothers or sisters, the statement my father’s son is himself. A shortened version would it is in this man’s dad is myself, so he is the father of the man in the picture.
No the is talking around his brother. The is simply saying that is poor. In other words he’s saying…. (Ladies and gentelmen I have actually non!) then he talks about his dad son… This mans father is my father’s son.It’s like shake spear? Brothers and also sisters! Or a black color shake spear… Its favor saying wuz up mine brothers and sisters….
Even if he to be saying he was poor, the still wouldn’t be himself. “This man’s father…”. Think about that who that is because that a couple of minutes. Then about who her “father’s son” is if you don’t have any type of siblings. Then placed the 2 together.
The hatchet “and sisters” is extraneous. The answer would be the same if the term was omitted.
Simply put, that is talking around his half-brother. Very same father, various mother; therefore, the guy in the picture is his nephew.
If ns am a guy with no brothers, climate “my father’s son” is simply “me.”So we can substitute that in, and we get, “That man’s dad is (me).”He’s looking in ~ a picture of his son.
The answer to it is “”my son””……according come d speaker,he had actually no siblings.Pointing to his picture,he said”but dis man’s father(referring come me or i m sorry is myself) is my father’s son” referring to himself…..therefore the speak is “my Son”.
I understand the answer states his son yet that makes no sense….why would certainly he describe himself together my dad …his fathers boy minus an additional brother would be himself
It’s himself-No siblingsThat mans father (HIMSELFs father)Is mine fathers kid (HIS FATHER) son which would be him
Thanks I’m best ?
The guy in the photo is his son,It can also be himself too its weird. Yet replace the male in the photo with a girl (which is exactly how I constantly heard the riddle), climate ask who is the girl in the picture to the man looking in ~ the picture.
Brothers and sisters I have none but that girl’s father is mine father’s son.
The guy looking in ~ the snapshot is absolutely the man in the picture’s father, unless you believe the evangelical version, i m sorry should have a comma, colon, or also a semi-colon after “Brothers and also Sisters”.I think I very first remember hearing that as:“I to be looking at a photo of a man. This man’s father is my father’s son.” who is the man in the picture.The answer to that one is either the riddler’s son, or his nephew, together ambiguated by the lack of point out of siblings.
Dave states January 29, 2016
He lookin in mirror
mary claims February 8, 2016
mary claims February 8, 2016
That Man’ is my father’s son. If I have no brothers and sisters climate my father’s son have the right to only be me.
Lance states march 2, 2016
How around his clone!
Sweet Stylin states in march 31, 2016
it’s his son, right?
Nebulous states April 4, 2016
The question’s wording consists of too much noise. Resolving this type of difficulty requires identifying the signal in ~ the noise. Favor a talented phase magician, the numerous unnecessary words, uncommon sentence structures, and even the rhyming offer as misdirection indigenous the answer.
If ns restate the concern using quick sentences and also only the vital data, look just how easy the price comes:1. If ns don’t have any type of brothers, who is mine father’s son?2. Provided the above, what man could case my father’s boy (me) as his father?
Damo states April 17, 2016
Had a substantial argument about this riddle this particular day (I command a sad life!). A friend of mine called me the correct answer is the it’s a photo of himself. I say it makes no sense. If the guy in the photo is himself and also he says that man father (his father), is my father’s son. For this reason to the means, his dad is his father’s son. Possibly I’m missing something? …
Sii claims April 24, 2016
He’s talking around himself but simply put it doesn’t ask whom he is talking about, the asks that is the man, This man’s dad is mine father’s son…..the male is his son
Dan I states might 1, 2016
D guy in d mirror is his son…
mark states may 1, 2016
the key is “my father’s son”, it can only it is in himself. He is looking in ~ a picture of himself.
ToiletPolice says might 15, 2016
This riddle has actually 2 answers, both that which are correct in referral to “this man”:
1. Self (if he’s looking in ~ a picture of himself, climate his father’s kid would it is in himself)2. His child (if he’s looking in ~ a snapshot of his son, climate his son’s dad is the same human as “my father’s son”)
To eliminate the ambiguity, this riddle demands a huge disclaimer like: “it’s no himself”
Dan claims might 15, 2016
ToiletPolice over there is no ambiguity. The man can never be looking in ~ himself. That states, “This man’s father”. Space you saying he have the right to be his very own father?
Patrick states respectable 19, 2016
“My father’s son” is himself, obviously.He has no brothers or sisters, for this reason it has to be himself.For the purposes of clarity, let’s have actually this guy call himself Andy.
So, substitute it.
“Brothers and sisters, I have none, but this man’s dad is Andy.”
Under what circumstance would Andy, himself, be the person in the photograph’s father?
If, and only if, he to be looking at a photo of his son.
Kyser claims October 26, 2016
Its his dads illegitimate son on his mother’s sidel.
Humility states November 10, 2016
He is looking at the picture of a male on the wall,then he stated to himself,This mans father (the father of the guy in the picture)is mine father’s son(the man speaking is the only son that his very own father,then ,the male in the photo is a kid to the guy speaking.) to clear u well, the concern says that is the guy in the picture,and not who is the male speaking, so because of this : The man in the snapshot is a kid to th guy speaking
Greg claims December 4, 2016
There space 2 answers:1) The direct approach. Take it a selfie, look at it and repeat the riddle. Clear the man speaking and also the man in the pic are the exact same person.2) reverse engineering: start at the back. My fathers son is me. That man father is me. That male is my son.A perfect example of dilution with reverse engineering.
Timmy Chase says January 12, 2017
You males are all idiots, it’s clear his son…. You have to work backwards my “fathers son” if he has no brothers and sister must be himself, but WAIT over there is another part. “That man father” therefore that man father is himself…. Who can it be???? His kid you morons. It’s his son.Son.Son.
shahin says January 22, 2017
the answer is his Son.end the story.
Billy says in march 9, 2017
This have to be a standard test because that operating any type of heavy machinery.
Does everyone saying “it’s clearly himself” no realise just how wrong lock are? Is this all some sophisticated joke ~ above me?
“That man’s father is mine fathers son”
Imagine he just said
“That male is my dad son”
Then is him obviously.
Now go check out the heat again
“That man’s father…. Is mine fathers son”
Come on. Don’t it is in so dumb.
Lockhart says April 7, 2017
The prize is the male son. The who is looking at the snapshot is looking at a photo of his son. Explanation- put yourself in the guy looking in ~ the picture shoes. If i look at a photo and also say I have no brother or sister obviously I’m the just child. Therefore if ns look at this photograph of a man and also say this guy farther. I would be talking around myself. Then say his father is my dad son. I’m talking around myself. Therefore the guy in the phot deserve to only it is in my son since I have actually no brother or sisters
Kevon claims may 15, 2017
Only in part weird alternating reality whereby anything is feasible would it is in this guys transgender 2nd cousin. I’ve disputed this because that years with numerous people and every time castle answer he is spring at self
It seems I’ve been surrounding by idiots my totality life and. O one can see it’s his son, even said it out with the wife for the critical 30 mins prior to she agreed.
Reading every the comments provided amusement tho
Ioane papalii claims July 22, 2017
A nephew, my brothers son.
Vaibhav says April 14, 2018
HIS son is the answer
rgc states might 5, 2018
There is only ONE correct answer. Not two. And also the correct answer is that the male is looking in ~ a photo of his son. THINK about it, people. It’s not progressed music theory!
Arun claims January 17, 2019
There are 2 possibilities, neither of which is himself.(1) His son(2) His nephew
Tomm claims in march 1, 2019
There space not 2 possibilities, together Arun claims. The prize is it’s his son. It can’t be his nephew because he has actually no brothers or sisters, because of this no nephews or nieces.
LIZA claims respectable 20, 2019
come on…. The price is simple… he is looking at a picture of himself!
Jackson earle states February 18, 2020
It’s himselfYou can’t be your own father and also it’s says “MY fathers son” MY no his
Dan states February 18, 2020
Jackson earle my father’s son is without doubt himself, yet he claims this man’s father is himself.
Sergio states might 14, 2020
Is the stepbrother!!!
Veritas states October 28, 2020
To settle this, break it down.‘Brothers and sisters I have actually none’ = i’m an just child‘Yet this man’s father is my father’s son’ = This man’s father is mePut the all together – ns an only child and this man’s dad is me – the photo is the his son.
Ron claims march 31, 2021
This sparked countless family rifts going ago to the 60sHow on planet can it no be the son?
Mikegee claims July 18, 2021
To start with, let’s say the speak is looking in ~ a picture of his boy (that man, so not woman). Then, the man’s dad (the speaker) is mine father’s son (the speaker). Fixed once and for all.
Andy states July 20, 2021
In answer to the question. Who is the male in the picture?. I put myself come the test. I came into the sitting room and also a photo of myself of many years back was top top the wall. I looked in ~ it and then I check out the rhyme. “Brothers sisters. I have none, however that man’s father is my father-son. The price is Myself. Then ns went out and also entered the room again. This time ns stared as a picture of mine son. And also repeated the rhyme. The price was. Mine Son.. It’s a trick and the rhyme is there to confuse us. Otherwise so numerous would not be ideal or wrong, and also Google who are the professionals did no come up through a identify answer. :-)
Dan claims July 20, 2021
Andy You’re incorrect on the an initial example. It simplifies come “that man’s father is me”, and you can not be your very own father. (Your father’s boy is girlfriend if you have actually no siblings).
Billy Bob claims august 13, 2021
This riddle was invented to assist smart world in the human being identify who around them is stupid, so the they have the right to avoid those people. (And, yes, the one and also only feasible answer to the riddle is that he is looking at a snapshot of his son.)
sidd claims September 21, 2021
The man comes how you interpret “he?”
Is the topic of the inquiry (he) “That man” or “That man’s father”
In english language this is referred to as an faint antecedent. The pronoun “he” can refer come “That man” or “That man’s father”
Now if you say “I am looking in ~ a snapshot of someone and that man’s father is…” then the it could seem logical the the subject of my concern is the person I am looking at in the picture, which would clearly(?) suggest the topic of my question (he) is “that man”
But in another context, i am in a crowed room, and also I am talk to a friend. I allude to a person across the room and also say “that man’s father offered to it is in
Of course, in either case the opposite might be true, and hence the ambiguity.
See more: What Is Another Name For The Opposite Of A Number, Synonyms For Opposite Number
which provides this the perfect riddle/bar bet**… because after the has actually concluded their logic, you have the right to simply switch your context and say no, “he” describes